‘HOMECOMING’ BY NOEL CORBETT: A FORGOTTEN POEM FROM THE BATTLE OF JUTLAND, JUNE 1916

The best of the Western Front war poets of 1914-1918 are wonderfully graphic, matching, even outstripping, photographers, filmmakers and artists in their depiction of the courage, desperation and sheer horror of the trench fighting. Here, for example, are some lines from ‘France, 1917’, by Theodore Percival (T.P.) Cameron Wilson (1888-1918), school master turned infantry captain, who wrote poems and powerful letters (1) about his battle experiences before he was killed during the costly German March offensive and advance of 1918:

The bodies of men lay down in the dark of the earth:
Young flesh, through which life shines a friendly flame,
Was crumbled green in the fingers of decay….
Among the last year’s oats and thistles lay
A forgotten boy, who hid as though in shame
A face that the rats had eaten…Thistle seeds
Danced daintily above the rebel weeds.
Old wire crept through grass there like a snake,
Orange – red in the sunlight, cruel as lust.
And a dead hand groped blindly from the mould….
A dandelion flamed through ribs – like a heart of gold,
And stink of rotten flesh came up from the dust…(2)

Wilson was a close friend of Harold Monro (1879-1932), who, in his Poetry Bookshop in Bloomsbury, worked at the heart of the ‘Georgian’ poetry movement. Wilson, like Wilfred Owen, was proud to count himself among the Georgians and loved their close observation of nature. In his Western Front poems, he used this to create a world, not of beauty, but of horror and ugliness.

When we look at poems from the sea warfare of the time, it is a very different story. Very few poems convey the sheer terror of war life in the Royal or Merchant Navies. Some of these were composed by civilian writers.

Alfred Noyes (1880-1958) for instance, already a very popular poet by 1914 thanks in part to the success of ‘The Highwayman’ (3) had also won serious international attention with his prophetic anti-war poem ‘The Wine Press’ (1913) (4). An American critic commented on his ‘fervent hatred of war… and its ultimate horror’. In 1914, Noyes, unfit to serve himself, joined John Buchan’s propaganda department in the Foreign Office where he produced books and poems to support the war effort.

One of the best was Open Boats (1917) which, although propaganda, was poignant in telling of the dreadful fates of men and women cast adrift in small boats after their ships were sunk by German and Austrian submarines. The short chapters, each dealing with tragic episodes of sea war, were interspersed with poems – admittedly not Noyes’s best.  One poem however ‘An Open Boat’ (quoted in full below) must surely have been written for this book but it was possibly considered too grim for the wartime audience. It finally appeared somewhat unnoticed in a post-war collection (6). In four bleak quatrains, we see a crowded boat drifting on a restless sea. A woman clings on to her dead husband. The sailor in charge knows that the corpse must be thrown overboard as the boat is too heavy. The argument continues in a dialogue of anonymous italics. Then the narrative jumps forward to a stark, empty sea: the boat and its troubled people are gone. The poem, like Noyes’s prose sketches, records what he called ‘the numerous obscure murders of the innocent and helpless at sea’:

O what is that whimpering there in the darkness?
“Let him lie in my arms. He is breathing, I know.
Look. I’ll wrap all my hair round his neck.”–“The sea’s rising,
The boat must be lightened. He’s dead. He must go.”


See–quick–by that flash, where the bitter foam tosses,
The cloud of white faces, in the black open boat,
And the wild pleading woman that clasps her dead lover
And wraps her loose hair round his breast and his throat.

“Come, lady, he’s dead.” “No, I feel his heart beating.
He’s living, I know. But he’s numbed with the cold.
See, I’m wrapping my hair all around him to warm him”—-
–“No. We can’t keep the dead, dear. Come, loosen your hold.


“Come. Loosen your fingers.”–“O God, let me keep him!”
O, hide it, black night! Let the winds have their way!
For there are no voices or ghosts from that darkness,
To fret the bare seas at the breaking of day.

Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936), at the height of his fame and influence by the time of the First World War, was keen to support the war effort through his writing. He was encouraged to write newspaper articles and poems based on visits to Royal Navy bases at Dover and Harwich. Collected into short books (7), the sketches of Navy life on minesweepers, destroyers and submarines proved popular (some of the poems were set to music by Elgar) and were much reprinted although their reputation has not sustained as much perhaps as his other, earlier verse. An exception is his celebrated elegy, ‘My Boy Jack’, about a sailor lost at the Battle of Jutland (8).  Another sea poem, ‘The Changelings’ (9), has also retained its power. Two members of the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve, one in peacetime a bank manager, the other a grocer’s clerk, reflect on the strange and terrifying parenthesis in their lives: their thousand days of war service on ‘the dreadful seas’. There were the panic and tiredness, the giant waves, the horror of bodies taken from the water, the ‘pied craft’ (dazzle-painted ships) glimpsed in battle, the ‘battered liners’ that sank, taking hundreds with them into the dark. The language is sharp; the images crisp. In Debits and Credits, a collection of stories and poems, ‘The Sea Constables’ story is directly preceded by a poem in which four R.N.V.R. men discuss their treatment of a neutral ship carrying oil to the enemy. They hound its captain to his death. There is none of this anger in the poem which expresses wonderment at the fantastic experience that the war has given to quite ordinary men:

1
Or ever the battered liners sank
With their passengers to the dark,
I was head of a Walworth Bank,
And you were a grocer’s clerk.
2
I was a dealer in stocks and shares,
And you in butters and teas;
And we both abandoned our own affairs
And took to the dreadful seas.
3
Wet and worry about our ways–
Panic, onset and flight–
Had us in charge for a thousand days
And thousand-year-long night.
4
We saw more than the nights could hide–
More than the waves could keep–
And–certain faces over the side
Which do not go from our sleep.
5
We were more tired than words can tell
While the pied craft fled by,
And the swinging mounds of the Western swell
Hoisted us Heavens-high . . .
6
Now there is nothing–not even our rank–
To witness what we have been;
And I am returned to my Walworth Bank,
And you to your margarine!

Beyond professional poets of the Noyes-Kipling sort there were Royal Navy sailor-poets but their freedom of expression was curtailed by war-time circumstance.  Some of the Navy ships produced their own magazines and papers and it was there, at first, that the sailor writers thought to place their poems. Obviously, the authorities would frown on writing that questioned the Navy’s mission or threatened crew morale. The public at large keenly admired the Navy and its great tradition from Drake and Nelson to the modern Dreadnought battleships. Its opinion would not tolerate anti-sea war sentiments.

Two sailor – poets produced outstanding work that survives in anthologies: Edward Hilton – Young (1879-1960) and Noel Corbett (1887-1962). At Cambridge, Young excelled in science and developed his life-long interests in mathematics and economics. He also became involved with the Bloomsbury Group and, in 1909, found himself proposing to Virginia Woolf in a punt (he was rejected). When war came, he was commissioned into the R. N. V. R. and, with his expertise in codes, found himself in the great Naval base at Scapa Flow on Admiral Jellicoe’s flagship, the Iron Duke. During the frustrating ‘inoccupation’ before the Battle of Jutland in 1916, he wrote poems about what he saw around him. There was, in one instance, a striking impression of work in a gun-turret during live-firing; in ‘North Sea Stars’ a reflection on the greatness of England; in ‘Sunset Afloat’, a pride in the fine Naval tradition, the inherited laurels that were now being held to be passed on to the next generation. Some poems appeared in the ship’s newspaper, the Ducal Weekly, others in the Morning Post or the Cornhill Magazine. They were collected post-war in A Muse at Sea (10). Only after the war, in a memoir (11), did Young express his on-ship fears of mines and torpedoes. Later war poems – poignant elegies, like ‘In the Third Year of the War’ or ‘Return’, for Friends Lost in Conflict – are full of regret but show no loss of faith in ‘the great England of history’. Young survived to become, in due course, an important man, 1st Baron Kennet, who served in the Baldwin / Chamberlain inter-war governments.

Noel Corbett was another brave and determined Naval officer. Son of an actor, he was born in Lyme Regis and joined the Navy as a cadet in 1903. He was quickly promoted. In 1911, he received the Sea Gallantry Medal for helping to save passengers and crew from a British liner wrecked on the Moroccan coast. In May 1916, he was serving on the battle- cruiser HMS Indomitable, one of a squadron of three based temporarily (for gunnery practice) with the Grand Fleet at Scapa Flow in the Orkneys in Scotland.  The battle-cruisers were relatively new ships and they had their own up-to-date base at Rosyth on the River Forth near Edinburgh. They were heavily armed and fast but had restricted armour and were designed to deal with German coastal raiders like those which attacked Scarborough in 1914.

When news came (in late May 1916) of the sailing of the German High Seas Fleet into the North Sea, Admiral Jellicoe’s Grand Fleet and Admiral Beatty’s secondary group came out to meet their enemy. On 31st May, before he could unite with Jellicoe, Beatty found his ships in action against a strong German force. The six battle-cruisers of Beatty’s force bore the brunt. All were badly damaged, and Indefatigable and Queen Mary blew up and sank. Later Invincible shared their fate.

Thousands of men perished. Was the cause of the disasters the battle-cruisers’ ineffective armour or their poor shells which broke up on impact with enemy ships? Mike Farquharson-Roberts, in his recent history of the Royal Navy (12), suggests that poor discipline in the gun-turrets caused the explosions: anti-flash shutters had been removed to improve the rate of fire. Bags of propellant had been removed from protective cases and caught fire quickly if an enemy shell pierced the turret.

When the Battle was over, the damaged ships limped slowly home. Both sides spoke of victory but the fact that the German Fleet remained largely inactive thereafter gives the British Grand Fleet the better claim.

Noel Corbett had seen out the battle on Indomitable. To escape the shock and sorrow at the loss of so many close ship – mates, he turned again to poetry. He had already published a collection, A Naval Motley (13). Most had appeared in journals like The Navy Magazine or The Naval and Military Record. The poems aimed to please the cheerful Jack Tar who smiles from the cover: ‘To a Plum Duff’,’ The Bores of the Navy’, ‘To a Naval Cadet (died August 1914)’, or ‘The Old Cruiser’ which tells its own story as it is sailed to the breaker’s yard. Yet some are more serious. Corbett describes battle-cruisers leaving Rosyth in ‘The Sailing of the Fleet’ (14). The great ships, ‘The Might of England’, are the focus but he finds time to imagine the watching sailors’ families:

‘From the thronged piers
Faintly, the sound of cheers
Tossed by the winds afar.’

In late 1917, he composed another longer poem, ‘Homecoming’, this time set after Jutland, imagining the return of the surviving, damaged battle-cruisers to Rosyth. Surprisingly, he sent the poem to the magazine Land and Water (15), edited by the dynamic Hilaire Belloc (1870-1953) who, after 1916, converted a field sports paper into a widely read commentary on the progress of the war. Its finest achievement was its choice of progressive war poetry and art. Here readers could find new war poems by Robert Graves, Sherard Vines, Gilbert Frankau or Edgell Rickword, and study Western Front drawings and prints by Paul Nash, Gerald Spencer Pryse and Edward Handley-Read.  Corbett addressed himself to this new audience, turning aside from everything he had written before.

In ‘The Sailing of the Fleet’, the watching Navy families were seen in the far distance. Now, in ‘Homecoming’ (16), we are shockingly close, inside the half-silent, desolate crowd on the piers by the Forth Bridge, which looks ominous and death-like in the mist. The narrator is one of the waiting women, full of foreboding about the return. Corbett creates a grey mood on a grey June day. It is a very tactile poem: one can see the weeds of the pier, feel the thin, cold rain, hear the sigh of the women and the sea-birds’ sad cries. Glory and the idea of Victory have faded. Drake and Nelson have vanished. The arrival of the shockingly damaged ships is told through broken fragments of dialogue among the women and girls. The despairing climax comes in the last line as the watchers realise that at least one of the battle-cruisers has not returned.

HOMECOMING

I stood upon the weed-hung, glistening pier
Waiting. And the grey, slow, whispering tide
Eddied about the stones and, gaunt and drear –
Like some gigantic skeleton astride
The mist-enshrouded Forth – the Bridge rose sheer.
And other women, mother, wife, and bride,
Were waiting too: and in their eyes lurked Fear.
Fear froze the breath upon their trembling lips
That bravely lied to comfort one another.

I heard one pale-faced girl-wife whisper, “Mother,
Nothing could happen to those modern ships?
It’s not as if she were an old one.” I
Caught the answer, “Darling, if God so wills…”
Then silence but for sea – birds’ mournful calling
And the slow tide.
                             A thin, cold rain was falling
And the grey sea was one with the weeping sky
And the stark trees veiled upon the nearer hills.

Then from the little group a pent-up sigh
Escaped and, looking seaward, through the veil
I saw the lean, grim Battle-Cruisers steer;
And in their shell-torn sides could read the tale
Of the price paid for Victory.            
A faint cheer
Trembled and died upon the heavy air.

Silent and slow they passed.                               
“One, two, three.”
I heard a woman count. “Are there no more?”
“Mother, my eyes are blurred; I cannot see.
Is there another – count if there be not four?”
The grey fog closed behind them like a door
Shutting out Hope. A sudden, heart-wrung cry
Rang, shuddering, low, pregnant with all despair,
“She is not there. Christ! Mother, she is not there.”

The anguish of the conclusion probably reflected Corbett’s own shock, grief and restrained anger at the loss of so many comrades.

Corbett remained in the Navy after the war and was steadily promoted. One of his ships was the ill-fated battle–cruiser, H. M. S. Hood. Although he retired in 1933, he was recalled to the Navy in 1940 when he became, for five years, Governor of the Faroe Islands, leased to Britain by Denmark after the Germans occupied that country. It seems that he published no more poems after ‘Homecoming’, that moving elegy for the dead sailors of the Battle of Jutland.
                                                                         

(1) Magpies in Picardy: The Poetry Bookshop 1919.
(2)  Ibid. ‘France 1917’ pp 38-42.
(3)’The Highwayman’: Blackwood’s Magazine: August 1906.
(4) ‘The Wine Press: a Tale of War’: William Blackwood and Sons 1913.
(5) Open boats: the fate of merchant ships in war: William Blackwood and Sons 1917.
(6) The Elfin Artists and Other Poems: William Blackwood and Sons 1920 p 20.
(7) Sea Warfare: The fFringes of the fFleet (1915); Tales of the Trade (1916); Destroyers at Jutland (1916)): Macmillan and Co. Ltd. 1916.
(8) The poem appeared untitled as preface to Destroyers at Jutland (1916). It is suggested that it also refers obliquely to Kipling’s own son, John, killed on the Western Front at Loos in September 1915.
(9)  Debits and Credits: Macmillan and Co. Ltd. 1926; The Cambridge Edition of the Poems of Rudyard Kipling (3 Vols) ed. Thomas Pinney: Cambridge University Press 2013. This poem is in Vol II p 997. A sub-title (R. N. V..R..) was added in 1927.
(10) A muse at Sea: Edward Hilton Young: Sidgwick and Jackson 1919.
(11) By Sea and Land: Edward Hilton Young: Jack (London) 1920.
(12) A History of the Royal Navy: World War 1:  M. Farquharson-Roberts: I. B. Tauris / Royal Navy Museum 2014 pp 97-100.
(13) A Naval Motley: verses written at sea during the war and before it: Lieut. N. M. F. Corbett R.N.: Methuen and Co. Ltd. 1916.
(14) ‘The Sailing of the Fleet’: N. M. F. Corbett: A Naval Motley: Methuen and Co. Ltd.1916 pp 7-8.
(15) Land and Water: The World’s War (1916-1920) had been The Country Gentleman and Land and Water (1905-1916) and was absorbed by The Field (1920 onwards).
(16) ‘Homecoming’: Noel Corbett: Land and Water 7 February 1918 p 20.